Media

|

Transcript | News24 Credlin | 17 November 2026

November 17, 2026

Tuesday, 17 November 2026
Topics: Labor’s backpackers backflip, Labor's tax on small business, Chris Bowen wants Australians to pay more for global climate plans, NDIS paying billions to non-citizens, Muslim brotherhood in Australia
E&OE…………………………………………………………………………………………

PETA CREDLIN: National issues, let's get across them now, joining me now a Victorian, senator of course, Shadow Defence Minister James Paterson. Let's start with that backflip today from the government over visas in relation to backpackers. Farmers are thrilled, it's a common sense move. I know you guys, the Coalition, have had a big win, but it led me to thinking, when I looked at the treasurer out there today trying to sort of talk up MYEFO. What is there left in this Budget? Seems to have been changed, or scrapped, or withdrawn.

SENATOR JAMES PATERSON: Well, can Labor get anything right on migration? I mean, they got it wrong on the way up. They brought in too many people in their first four years, about one and a half million people. When they belatedly recognised that was a problem and said they had to bring it down, they've got it on the wrong way down too. They've cut the wrong sort of people out of the country - critical workers to make sure that the fruit doesn't rot on the vines and our farmers can get food on the table. Just an extraordinary stuff up that they were warned about by the Farmers' Federation, by us and many others. Finally, though, they've back-flipped. I think you're right, this is a budget which is in tatters. Every key element has been back-flipped or modified in some way. The big remaining thing they haven't passed is their trust changes, which is really a tax on small business. Let's see if they can even get that through the Senate.

CREDLIN: There was concern today too with those trust changes that when the Parliament resumes next week, they will go after religious organisations, schools and charities.

PATERSON: So the Greens have said their condition of supporting it, because obviously the Coalition is not going to support higher taxes on small business, is that an exemption for donations to religious charities would be taken out. So you'd be taxed on a donation from a trust to a religious charity. Now, if Labor balks at that, if they go along with that, it would be a massive hit to the charitable sector. So many charities that do such good work in the religious space. So that would be an extraordinary thing for the government to do, but they are desperate, and maybe they just want to get it through.

CREDLIN: Let's go back to the COP meeting in Turkey. We'll leave the crude analysis regarding the Prime Minister to one side. We see the communiqué today, the draft communiqué. And in it, it's got this requirement that rich nations like, so-called rich nations, like Australia, need to pay three times the climate funds into the United Nations. Now, over the last five years, we've paid something of $8 billion. That would take it up to $32 billion. At the same time, we're saying to Australians your power prices, wholesale power prices, are set to triple as well.

PATERSON: Peta, I thought the $32,000 on coffee was bad. I thought that $71,000 on limos was bad, but this is just extraordinary. It is not in Australia's national interest. And let's remember, Chris Bowen is the president of negotiations at COP. He presides over this communique. He's the one who's got to get it signed and agreed to. This is not in Australia's national interest, and an Angus Taylor led Coalition government would never agree to handing over Australian taxpayers' money to the United Nations for climate change when, as you say, small businesses, families, and individuals can't afford to pay their electricity bills.

CREDLIN: It wasn't that long ago when Angus had his budget in-reply speech and said that welfare will only be for Australian citizens and the left, the government, the Greens went after you very hard, accusing you of being discriminatory. You had a big win this week from the Parliamentary Budget Office.

PATERSON: The reaction of most Australians when they heard that was, we thought that welfare was only for Australians to begin with. They were shocked to learn that non-citizens were, for example, getting first home owner grants to buy homes in Australia. But we discovered this week from the Parliamentary Budget Office that of the $50 billion we spend a year on the NDIS, 10% of that or $5 billion, is going to non-citizens. Now we've said we'll change that. Obviously we'll grandfather existing participants, but any new migrant who comes to Australia needs to become a citizen before they access generous programs like the NDIS. We just can't afford to be funding non-citizens to get that kind of support.

CREDLIN: Just quickly on a national security portfolio issue, last night I was speaking to David Craig, a former AFP Superintendent. He is very concerned about credible evidence that there are deep roots of the Muslim Brotherhood embedded in Australia now. Let's have a listen to what he said.

[CLIP START]

DAVID CRAIG: It has two fronts. One is the terrorism, straight-up terrorism, like Hamas was born out of the Muslim Brotherhood. The second is political influence to advance Islamic control and dominance. And we, in Australia, we've got no ban and no plan.

[CLIP END]

PATERSON: David is right to be concerned. For decades, the Muslim Brotherhood has been a hugely intellectually influential Sunni Islamist organisation. It's inspired Osama Bin Laden and Al-Qaeda. And if they are active in Australia, that is a massive national security problem. My view is this is best investigated by the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security. When I chaired that under the Morrison government, we investigated Hamas and Hezbollah, and that led to a recommendation to broaden those terrorism listings from just the militant wings of those organisations to the whole organisation, and those recommendations were adopted by the Morrison Government. So this is bread and butter work for the Intelligence Committee. It can get the classified briefings, it can get to the bottom of this, and I think they'll find there is a good case to list the Muslim Brotherhood as a terrorist organisation too.

CREDLIN: So will you support that push by people like Dave Craig? I know he's had a thousand sign that petition overnight. Will you support their push back in Canberra?

PATERSON: I'm very supportive. I think this is a dangerous organisation. We've banned Hizb ut-Tahrir recently as an extremist organisation. That legislation is being challenged in the High Court, but let's have a look at the Muslim Brotherhood too. It's been enormously influential in a very dangerous way.

CREDLIN: James Paterson, thank you.

ENDS

Recent News

All Posts